Charts

Where Student Loans Hurt the Most

Published

on

Americans collectively owe $1.863 trillion in student loans spread across roughly 43 million borrowers. A new analysis from Student Choice examines whether a $400 monthly payment is as affordable in every state. The gap between the most and least affordable states paints a picture of the complexities of debt, living expenses, and wages.

Student Choice scored 50 states on five metrics weighted by how directly living there affects student loan affordability. The heaviest metric is the student-loan-to-income ratio (40%), followed by delinquency rate (20%), rent-to-income ratio (15%), household debt-to-income ratio (15%), and cost of living (10%). Each state gets a final score, and a higher score means loans are harder to afford. Monthly payments are estimated from Department of Education data, assuming a 5.99% interest rate and a standard 10-year repayment plan.

Click below to zoom.

Mississippi is the least affordable state, largely because of low incomes. The per capita personal income in this state is $54,433, the lowest in the country. That means an average loan payment of $418 a month takes up 9.2% of income. Mississippi also has the nation’s highest delinquency rate, with 13.4% of student loan balances at 90 days or more past due.

The article makes a stark comparison with Connecticut borrowers who pay about the same amount each month at $422 but earn twice as much, so that payments take up just 4.9% of their income.

South Carolina, Georgia, and Alabama follow Mississippi, with much of the South clustered at the top of the ranking. Hawaii is the biggest outlier in the top 10. Its cost-of-living index of 185.8 is nearly double the national average, pushing the state to fifth place.

North Dakota is the most affordable state, with the lowest average loan balance at $29,762, the lowest average monthly payment at $330, and the lowest rent-to-income ratio in the nation at 24.2%. South Dakota trails by .31 points and has a lower delinquency rate than its neighbor. The rest of the top 10 most affordable states are Wisconsin, New Hampshire, Minnesota, and, believe it or not, Massachusetts and Connecticut. High incomes in those last two states offset their high costs.

The national average estimated student loan payment is $419 a month. Maryland borrowers pay the most on average at $503, followed by Georgia, Virginia, Florida, and New York. The article offers practical guidance, advising borrowers to keep loans under 10% of their income and to use the 50/30/20 budgeting rule. It also suggests borrowers refinance their loans if payments become unmanageable.

The article includes a detailed table with all the findings and data from all 50 states. You’ll find each state’s rank, federal loan balance, number of borrowers, average balance, estimated monthly payment, and per capita income. Borrowers comparing where to live or wondering whether their location is affecting the affordability of their loan payments can see exactly where their state lands, along with the details in this helpful study.

Click to comment

Trending

Exit mobile version